Smart contracts: legal nature and applicability to commercial relationships

Marcello Mantelli
Avvocato in Milan and Turin

Smart contract consists of a software, that is an IT protocol already programmed to automatically create contracts using blockchain technology.

Although Italy is one of the few countries in the world to have provided a definition of smart contract for the first time (contained in a national Decree “Decreto Semplificazioni”, art.8-ter paragraph 2), there are still many critical issues to be addressed, concerning first of all the legal nature of this type of contract.

Based on the provisions of art. 8-ter above, “a smart contract is defined as a computer program that operates on technologies based on distributed registers and whose execution automatically binds two or more parties based on predefined effects. […]”.

The main discussion, entirely doctrinal, therefore concerns the qualification of the smart contract, sometimes identified as a mixed contract consisting of an IT part (smart contract code) and a legal part (smart legal contract), sometimes as a contract with a virtual object, or such as a cybernetic contract.

At the basis of these hypotheses, the structure of the smart contract sees the contractual parties resorting to the use of this tool to regulate relationships whose effects are projected into the future, that is, when the smart contract will be executed.

However, a further distinction must be made with regard to smart contracts that execute an agreement already concluded previously between the parties and smart contracts that regulate the relationship from the beginning, thus constituting a real contract.

In the second case, in fact, it should be borne in mind that the smart contract is entirely written in computer language, which can only be understood by technical experts of the sector and – above all – it does not allow the expression of elaborate legal concepts, such as any specific clauses subject to a more flexible interpretation.

In other words, therefore, in approaching a form of technology that is undoubtedly attractive and full of advantages, the most problematic aspects related to this tool must also be considered. A valid solution certainly lies in being assisted in the drafting of the smart contract by an IT consultant expert on the subject.

In addition, another good practice may be to proceed with the drafting of a double document: on the one hand, the smart contract in computer language as envisaged; on the other hand, a traditional contract with the aim not only of reiterating what is expressed through smart contracts, but also of providing specific clauses that regulate what is not easily envisaged using computer language.

In this way it is possible to keep up with technological development, without giving up effective legal protection and safe instrument for both parties and for the commercial relationship established.

#smartcontract #newtechnologieslaw #onlinecontracts #blockchain #digitallaw #internationalcontracts #internationaltrade #internationalsale

Condividi su:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Dear Aurelia, the information you have provided are not sufficient for an answer which is subject to a professional engagement. In any case, we should study the provisions of the contract and identify governing law of the contract.If it does not provide anything on governing law then conflict law shall apply (in the most part of the countries likely the governing law will be the law of the country where the agent is domiciled). best regards Marcello Mantelli


I signed a contract with a fashion agency but there were no termination clauses in the contract and decided to withdraw it before one week after signature so sent them an email but after 14 days they sent me an email and asserted that because i didnt withdraw in legal deadlines i have to perform the contract and pay whole money.Noboday told me about any deadlines and nothing was in the contract!! Why did they claim such a thing?


Follow Us